99% of the time "Judeo-Christian" is antisemitic. And yes, I will absolutely elaborate on this if asked.
Credit: @Rabbit Cohen
Edit because this blew up far more than I expected and multiple people have asked for me to elaborate, here's a copy of my elaboration with follow up questions encouraged:
It's a messy topic and it's late here (I'm a bit sleepy), so feel free to ask follow up questions.
The short version of it is that Judeo-Christian is almost always used in one of two harmful ways:
1) To try and give more credibility and weight to something that is purely Christian by claiming that it's part of Judaism as well when it's not (like the above example, because Judaism explicitly permits abortions)
2) To try and talk about broader groupings of related faiths while ignoring the many other Abrahamic faiths (the proper term, though that one more often hurts the lesser known groups, don't use it unless you also know it applies to groups like the Baháʼí, which I'll admit even I know next to nothing about, but it's valid here because all I'm doing is naming their religious family)
Because many (cough most cough) teach a bastardized form of Judaism through the lens of Christianity, and because that's the only exposure many get to our faith... they get skewed harmful and hurtful ideas about us.
Some highlight examples:
* We don't have an established afterlife (we don't say there isn't one, we just have zero information on it if there is)
* We don't seek "eternal reward", the reward for our faith is being a better person than we were the day before
* We have forgiveness baked into our faith, and no it doesn't require animal sacrifice (it requires you to actually ask the person you wronged...)
* We thoroughly encourage arguing any topic with anyone (right time and place of course), and that includes picking a fight with God if you think they're wrong about something (you have a 99.9% chance of being wrong... but we commend the effort and every once in a while someone wins the argument)
* We have a rule, Pikuach Nefesh, roughly meaning that life is the highest commandment. Your well being takes precedence over your faith, if it would hurt you or others to be observant than you are exempt from that requirement. It's unacceptable to hurt others for your faith, and for yourself it's frowned upon
* We actively discourage conversion, it's allowed but it's not a trivial process. We don't want people to become Jews, we just want people to be better.
like this
reshared this
just adrienne
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to just adrienne • •@just adrienne @Rabbit Cohen And followed now!
This was from Facebook memories way back, and I like to when it fits, share those things over to the fediverse.
Adding an edit to explicitly credit because they deserve it.
like this
just adrienne, Claudius Link and Rabbit Cohen like this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Shiri Bailem • •like this
just adrienne, Rabbit Cohen and DoctorOctothorp like this.
Rabbit Cohen
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Scott Matter
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Scott Matter • •@Scott Matter things like:
Judeo-Christian Potluck - A potluck hosted by both Jews and Christians
Judeo-Christian Househould - A family in which one parent is Jewish and the other is Christian
like this
Rachel Evans, @stevewfolds, Scott Matter, crysterious, Dr. Mikaila, just adrienne and Dweebish like this.
wendinoakland has moved…
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to wendinoakland has moved… • •wendinoakland has moved… likes this.
wendinoakland has moved…
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to wendinoakland has moved… • •wendinoakland has moved…
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to wendinoakland has moved… • •@wboucek @Scott Matter yeah, false inclusivity is a huge pain in my ass...
It's why now is the time of year for me to greet people with Happy Holidays and Season's Greetings!
wendinoakland has moved… likes this.
wendinoakland has moved…
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Charlie Stross
in reply to Scott Matter • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Charlie Stross • •@Charlie Stross @Scott Matter antisemitism from ignorance is still antisemitism, it's accidental bigotry vs willful bigotry.
But also the EEE is a perfect reference point for what it's all about!
like this
novatorine 🏴🏳️⚧️, Liv, Citrus Reamer, ראַף 🟣, Patrick Poitras :opensuse: and just adrienne like this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@A13cui :perl: :opensuse: Thanks for asking!
It's a messy topic and it's late here (I'm a bit sleepy), so feel free to ask follow up questions.
The short version of it is that Judeo-Christian is almost always used in one of two harmful ways:
1) To try and give more credibility and weight to something that is purely Christian by claiming that it's part of Judaism as well when it's not (like the above example, because Judaism explicitly permits abortions)
2) To try and talk about broader groupings of related faiths while ignoring the many other Abrahamic faiths (the proper term, though that one more often hurts the lesser known groups, don't use it unless you also know it applies to groups like the Baháʼí, which I'll admit even I know next to nothing about, but it's valid here because all I'm doing is naming their religious family)
Because many (cough most cough) teach a bastardized form of Judaism through the lens of Christianity, and because that's the only exposure many get to our faith... they get skewed harmful and hurtful ideas about us.
Some highlight examples:
* We don't have an established afterlife (we don't say there isn't one, we just have zero information on it if there is)
* We don't seek "eternal reward", the reward for our faith is being a better person than we were the day before
* We have forgiveness baked into our faith, and no it doesn't require animal sacrifice (it requires you to actually ask the person you wronged...)
* We thoroughly encourage arguing any topic with anyone (right time and place of course), and that includes picking a fight with God if you think they're wrong about something (you have a 99.9% chance of being wrong... but we commend the effort and every once in a while someone wins the argument)
* We have a rule, Pikuach Nefesh, roughly meaning that life is the highest commandment. Your well being takes precedence over your faith, if it would hurt you or others to be observant than you are exempt from that requirement. It's unacceptable to hurt others for your faith, and for yourself it's frowned upon
* We actively discourage conversion, it's allowed but it's not a trivial process. We don't want people to become Jews, we just want people to be better.
like this
Leijona, Captain of the guard, tiphphin, Rachel Evans, spiegelmama, Jeremy Mallin, Weltschmerz à Gogo, farmer aby, Dan Howell, tuoba denrael, TinheadNed, 『-𝚍𝚜𝚛-』, crysterious, novatorine 🏴🏳️⚧️, the last heron, Robert, A. Lynn, Eduardo Padoan, fraggle, John :thisisfine:, Katja, Swift, Craig Reynolds, Andy H., miramarco, DressToKILT, chainsaw ma'am 🩸, AnAnarchist, Greg, Jonathan Beverley, Fabián Roque, Ember :autism:, Hart of the Wud, fibre 🐿, packbat is a social construct, Chadee 🦨🐋, Dream Witch 🌕 🌊, Deer Witch, aka ginger, Yingtai, :garfield:fuchsiaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa, rhizomatic arcade, Ysegrim, Tatra, Boundless, Amelia, a wandering happenstance, Darth Osler, Miss Havisham, Stapper, Verity :transHaskell::verifiedtransfem:, Eldan Goldenberg, Alexis, luluberlu (recette originale), Ana, Bry is Just. So Gay, Neon Ghost Rat, Liv, Citrus Reamer, BlackPixelDust: Art :autism:, Flatbush Gardener 🌈, reazonozaer, Cyber Trans Punk (It/They): The hidden arc, ✅Joe Stalin 1917 🇰🇵🇮🇷🇵🇸 🇨🇺🇨🇳, tobey maguire voice pizza time, jocanib, noahnah, Senil :maitai:, Ingot Montoya, Brian Tatosky, AnCuRuadh ΔΘ :verified_trans:, dumbass teenager moment, Jay :QueerCatMorning_Trans:, Tim is wearing a mask 🌈, Vera "Eat the Rich" Lycaon, Settantahertz, bimbo moomoo :cowtumble: and 32 other people like this.
reshared this
ReimanSaara, Jeremy Mallin, tuoba denrael, 『-𝚍𝚜𝚛-』, crysterious, novatorine 🏴🏳️⚧️, NeonSnake, lucapette, PH1BE5, Katja, Mike Richman, Richard Brockie, Murderbot🔫🤖, miramarco, chainsaw ma'am 🩸, Jonathan Beverley, Ember :autism:, Trans Gruber, packbat is a social construct, Psy Chuan :therian:, Deer Witch, Sven Slootweg, Yingtai, :garfield:fuchsiaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa, Darth Osler, ಚಿರಾಗ್ 🌹✊🏾Ⓥ🌱🇵🇸 (he/him), Alex, trinity-1686a, luluberlu (recette originale), Ana, Myz Lilith, Bry is Just. So Gay, Neon Ghost Rat, Skip Legday, lux :flag_nonbinary:🦊ΘΔ, Flatbush Gardener 🌈, Zach Fine, Cyber Trans Punk (It/They): The hidden arc, ✅Joe Stalin 1917 🇰🇵🇮🇷🇵🇸 🇨🇺🇨🇳, tobey maguire voice pizza time, noahnah, Rebecca Fielding-Miller, AnCuRuadh ΔΘ :verified_trans:, dumbass teenager moment, Jay :QueerCatMorning_Trans:, fluffy 💜, Johannes Silverfox 🦊, Reinder Dijkhuis Does Art, fuck it we ball, Nonny, Victims of Monads, CUTTLEFISH ATTORNEY AT LAW, The Doctor, Exiled New Yorker - Connie, Catherine Berry, NatalyaD, Jamey Sharp, Jovan, Paul Chernoff, Sebastian Dröge 🍵, Larry Garfield, rhapsodos 🇵🇸, Gina Peter Banyard, Writerphoebe, kuna, John P. :clubtwit:, average anthocyanin enjoyer, Chele and Quin~Kara reshared this.
'Spooky' Johnny
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Jacob Vardy
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
foo
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •novatorine 🏴🏳️⚧️
in reply to foo • • •like this
Shiri Bailem and Riot Disqordia like this.
Dr. Mikaila
in reply to foo • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to foo • •(A) when it's a person is a philosophical/religious argument, Judaism says at birth
(B) Pikuach Nefesh is specifically what permits it, abortion is permitted when it would cause harm to carry to term. It explicitly includes mental and economic health in that (if it would cause mental distress, if it would interfere with your ability to care for yourself or your family)
@A13cui :perl: :opensuse:
like this
Fabián Roque, Odd reverberations, Deer Witch, foo, Liv, Citrus Reamer, jocanib, Riot Disqordia, Scott Matter, Patrick Poitras :opensuse:, just adrienne, Leszek Karlik and spooky Ske-lil-ton 🦇 like this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@𐪅𐪀𐪈 𐪑𐪁𐪉
Not remotely a counter argument. For one equating Israel with Judaism is an anti-semitic (blood and soil, or just thinking a regional government is authoritative of a worldwide culture) or Zionist take (despised by non-zionists like myself as they are colonizers who think Israel can do no wrong).
Also, it's in the blog section talking about America. It's also precisely the wrong usage (it's calling America Judeo-Christian... it's just christian if anything). On top of that, internalized bigotry is a thing in minority groups.
like this
Liv, Citrus Reamer and just adrienne like this.
A. Lynn
Unknown parent • • •Sidenote: I understand why the combination would be complete trash in the topic of abortion. Anyone trying that might deserve a kick to the shin.
Shiri Bailem likes this.
ZenDra
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Evan Prodromou
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
fraggle
Unknown parent • • •Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@M_U @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: Judaism is both a religion and a cultural/"ethnic" group, "Judeo-Christian" is almost always used to refer to the religion of which my statements are representative of the vast vast majority of Judaism.
Also one of the distinct differences is that Atheism and the faith of Judaism are not incompatible. There are many atheist-jews because God actually isn't the center point of Judaism, the main point is the time tested rules (see the argue with everything/everyone) about becoming a better person.
We will always be used by minority groups referring to themselves, mostly because "the vast vast vast majority of us" is clumsy to say and people get the point that exceptions exist. Also, because it doesn't change the fact of the statement being made.
It's also why I mad the example points I did because they're central points that are agreed upon by all major sects as opposed to the many many points which are argued over (once again see the argue with everything/everyone... arguments are a past-time in Jewish culture)
like this
Liv, Citrus Reamer, Łukasz Langa, Clara "brick nogging" sparks, deco, Nauga Clown, just adrienne and Dweebish like this.
The Doctor reshared this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •Content warning: religious history
@A.L. Blacklyn @Scott Matter I think it's problematic because all of that is almost always presented from the filter of Christianity looking backwards. Jesus was absolutely a Jew and the vast vast majority of what he preached was in line with Jewish beliefs (if they hadn't shed Judaism as part of their faith and hadn't been co-assimilated with the entirety of Rome, it would be a very very different relationship).
The problem mostly comes from the fact that saying Judeo-Christian about those elements and times really should only be applied when you are intimately familiar with both faiths and are doing the hard work of removing the Christian filter from it.
Highlights on the Jewish view of Jesus:
* He fulfilled no significant prophecies regarding the Messiah (the whole point is the thousand years of peace), the vast vast majority of prophecies he's claimed to have fulfilled are mistranslations and/or completely out of context (ie. "virgin birth" came from "young woman of marriageable age" and a prophecy that had nothing to do with the messiah but was fulfilled in the following chapter)
* Trinitarianism isn't even universal among Christians, among Jews it's deeply deeply heretical as one of our long defining statements has been "God is One"
* Human sacrifice is abhorrent in Judaism, so the idea of Jesus being a sacrifice is abhorrent
* In Judaism we already have forgiveness, the biggest distinction is that God will only forgive how you've wronged God. For forgiveness over how you wronged another person you have to ask them. Imagine how you'd feel if I forgave my friend for stealing from you and then they looked you dead in the eye and said they were forgiven for stealing from you... I'd be an asshole, right?
like this
Ember :autism:, A. Lynn, Amelia, Liv, Citrus Reamer, :thufie: דגל שכור 🏴 :contains_thc:, just adrienne and essay necromancer like this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@0x506978656C526F626F74🦾🤖 in probably 50% of the cases absolutely!
They often use it as a stand-in for Abrahamic (which is often problematic, but has far far more legitimate uses) and I mention in my elaboration comment, though I go more narrow a mention the most obscure Abrahamic faith I know of (Baháʼí) to highlight both facts just because their obscurity I feel makes the point better (though I feel a little guilty for using them as a token, it is also in the effort of getting them and other groups recognition).
like this
Murderbot🔫🤖 and just adrienne like this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@ScepticalScot1 Correct on Judaism, it's an explicit thing.
To be clear, our faith doesn't blanket allow it either... but it's a tiny distinction with how broad our allowance is:
We don't consider it a person until it's birth, until then it's just a potential person (Jewish law only treats it as a person in cases of forced abortion or similar, ie. if you murder a pregnant person who wanted their child, then it's a double-homicide).
Judaism specifically says that abortion is permitted when the well-being of the person carrying it is threatened. But that sounds far more restrictive than it is because we have a broad view of well-being laid out, which includes mental health (being forced to carry a pregnancy you do not want and birth a child against your will is traumatic, therefore abortion is permitted because your mental health would be threatened by denying an abortion... which basically means abortion is permitted in the vast vast vast majority of cases)
(An example of times when it might not be permitted would be things like if they were in the middle of a psychotic episode)
just adrienne likes this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@Nicolai von Neudeck 🤒🤕 Oooooof, true but oooof.
I will forewarn against the usage there because many anti-theists (atheists with a grudge against all faiths) have picked up Judeo-Christian as well and would interpret that as accusing Judaism of also committing similar atrocities (though the government of Israel continually makes that a challenging topic...)
just adrienne likes this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •"Major Sects" - the large divisions of Judaism representing the vast vast majority of us
"Agreed upon" - Explicitly in our agreed mutual holy texts, considered major defining elements of our faith, or in the case of the afterlife not mentioned anywhere in our texts
Keep in mind that we have more religious texts than are included in the Christian "Old Testament", most significantly the Talmud which is accepted by all Jewish sects I know of and is where many of these elements are established.
How about this follow up: do you have more familiarity with Jewish cultures than a Jew? Do you know what I'm leaving off of the lists that differs between Jewish groups?
@M_U @A13cui :perl: :opensuse:
like this
aka ginger, Liv, Citrus Reamer and just adrienne like this.
DressToKILT
Unknown parent • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Tammy Garrison
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Tammy Garrison • •@Tammy Garrison Here's a link to my previous elaboration: https://foggyminds.com/display/c6ef095f-1864-c4b5-e122-cfb887278714
Feel free to ask follow up questions!
Shiri Bailem
2023-07-29 06:46:57
Tammy Garrison
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@Nicolai von Neudeck 🤒🤕 I have no ability to delete your post without you being on my server, though I'm not seeing it anymore either. I'd check with your admins to see if they maybe flagged it and didn't understand?
And the exact kinds of people I mentioned in my comment are the people who'd not understand because they're indoctrinated by christo-fascism and rejecting it without rejecting what they've learned from it.
just adrienne likes this.
Feygele Ⓐ Ⓥ🏳️⚧️
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Chadee 🦨🐋, Dream Witch 🌕 🌊
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Chadee 🦨🐋, Dream Witch 🌕 🌊 • •like this
Chadee 🦨🐋, Dream Witch 🌕 🌊 and Patrick Poitras :opensuse: like this.
Pedestriansfirst
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •e. hashman 🇵🇸
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Jewish religious movement characterized by the recognition of the written Torah alone as its supreme authority in Jewish religious law and theology.
Contributors to Wikimedia projects (Wikimedia Foundation, Inc.)Anthony Sorace
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Anthony Sorace • •@Anthony Sorace @Erika Ensign that falls under "No True Scotsman", they are Christian regardless of being a subset much the same as I won't claim that Zionists aren't jews despite holding objectionable views.
It's a logical fallacy used very often to avoid looking at issues in one's own social groups.
like this
Mr. Q The Pizza Demon, Adam, as the world falls down and just adrienne like this.
Anthony Sorace
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Aviva Gary
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Zach Fine
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Zach Fine
in reply to Zach Fine • • •Glyph
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •My Jewish Faith Makes Me Pro-abortion
Danya Ruttenberg (The Atlantic)Shiri Bailem likes this.
Zach Fine
in reply to Zach Fine • • •fluffy 💜
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •like this
Shiri Bailem and Riot Disqordia like this.
Zorin =^o.o^=
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •@a13cui It often feels like the Jewish faith has things figured out better than most belief systems.
Especially the "don't try to force others to follow your religion" part. That's a big awesome one.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to e. hashman 🇵🇸 • •@e. hashman :flag_bisexual: Again I said major sects and didn't say there are no exceptions.
I'm not going to entertain this line of arguments any further because I can't see a version of this being in good faith at this point.
MeredithW likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Pedestriansfirst • •like this
Alexis, ocdtrekkie, just adrienne and Leszek Karlik like this.
ראַף 🟣
Unknown parent • • •It's not really a tribute if it mostly gets used to mean Christian. It often implies the speaker doesn't understand or value the important differences between Jewish and Christian values. Also low-key islamaphobic
Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Zach Fine • •@Zach Fine @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: it's purpose is to prevent dilution of the faith.
The rejection is just the first step, there's also studying and being approved by a Bet Din (rabbinic court).
We want to insure people don't join the community and the immediately start screwing with our traditions and practices.
Pedestriansfirst
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Zach Fine • •just adrienne likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Zorin =^o.o^= • •just adrienne likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to fluffy 💜 • •@fluffy 💜 @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: It has slightly more legitimate usage, but only slightly.
Mostly just because it is the actual family name.
But yeah, it's too often used for faux-inclusivity.
like this
Alexis and just adrienne like this.
Pedestriansfirst
Unknown parent • • •Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@crows call me breadlady sure, I need to update the original to link this because it got way more traction than I expected!
Happy to answer follow ups!
https://foggyminds.com/display/c6ef095f-1864-c4b5-e122-cfb887278714
Shiri Bailem
2023-07-29 06:46:57
crows call me breadlady likes this.
Robrab
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Robrab • •@Robrab That's really a combination of anti-semitism and "No True Scotsman"
Most of the "old testament angry bits" are Christian interpretations or mistranslations.
Prime example is the verse they translate as "A man should not lie with another man as he would a woman" (anti-homosexuality) which is far more accurately translated as "A man should not lie with a boy as he would a woman" (anti-pedophilia). One of those two makes a hell of a lot more sense for stoning...
like this
Eugene and just adrienne like this.
Robrab
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
american
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to american • •american
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •american
in reply to american • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to american • •american
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
e. hashman 🇵🇸
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
CaptMorgan
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Content warning: religion
CaptMorgan
in reply to CaptMorgan • • •Content warning: religion
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Pedestriansfirst • •like this
Alexis and like jam or bootlaces like this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •like this
Scott Matter, just adrienne and A. Lynn like this.
fluffy 💜
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Riot Disqordia likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to CaptMorgan • •Content warning: religion
@CaptMorgan @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: This is a very flawed take and discounts the many interpretations and approaches different groups have to addressing these things.
For reference, I'm a Reform Jew: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_Judaism#Reform_Judaism
I will openly say that what you're saying absolutely applies to Orthodox Judaism and can somewhat apply to Conservative Judaism... there's a reason I'm a Reform Jew and not Orthodox lol
Also of note the "Old Testament" is not synonymous with all our texts or the Torah (the Torah is only the first five books). We have many texts that are not included in the Christian Bible.
like this
like jam or bootlaces, just adrienne and Dweebish like this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to fluffy 💜 • •like this
Alexis, Clara "brick nogging" sparks, fluffy 💜 and just adrienne like this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Zorin =^o.o^= • •@Zorin =^o.o^= @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: Also noting that a lot of the "have things figured out" comes from the outlook of arguing as a pastime. Since nothing is above debate, everything gets challenged constantly.
These days, it's not as visible because the vast majority of topics have been challenged to the point that there's little to argue... but there are absolutely topics being fought over (like for instance circumcision which is a very very touchy ongoing argument, mostly due to it's adjacency to the history of antisemitism)
like this
just adrienne, assertchris and Dweebish like this.
DemocritusDiscoBall
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to DemocritusDiscoBall • •DemocritusDiscoBall likes this.
DemocritusDiscoBall
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
DemocritusDiscoBall
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Like forfend popped out just now?
Why? Couldn’t tell ya, but it’s why I’m a much better writer than talker lol.
My best one of late was intransigent intelligence. Think the asd helps with popping the right sounds n meaning out at the right time.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to DemocritusDiscoBall • •@DemocritusDiscoBall ooh, such delightful words. I enjoy linguistics, so many fun quirks.
And isn't Intransigent Intelligence just all of us? It sounds to me like "Intelligence suffering from the backfire effect"
DemocritusDiscoBall
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •You would hope, but many people don’t continue to do research when they get disapproval, hate for it. In that case it was in reference to D Elisabeth Glassco who posts here as @Deglassco, about Black history, specifically all teh bs book banning etc GOP is pulling out to cover up the history of slavery.
People like her have the fortitude and intelligence to fight through the bs, read the hard hateful truth, and share with us. We need more brave, smart people to fight the good fight.
Shiri Bailem likes this.
DemocritusDiscoBall
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Intransigent unwilling to change one’s point of views, even under pressure
Intelligence, smart enough to see the truth.
So you need them both in how I mean the phrase. Because when you start talking about how life really is, you often get a LOT of hate from small minded authoritarians.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to DemocritusDiscoBall • •@DemocritusDiscoBall Yeah, it's basically the backfire effect and whether or not the person takes effort to combat it. It has nothing to do with smarts and everything to do with pure psychology.
The backfire effect is rooted in the fact that when we take a stance on an issue it incorporates into our identity, the stronger the stance the more it incorporates.
When faced with evidence that the position may be wrong, we experience cognitive dissonance and our brain reacts to that information as a threat. Our natural default response is to double down on whatever it is, both increasing the strength of your connection to it and even less critical of the details you're relying on to support your argument.
It's basically the reason you "can't win arguments on the internet", because if someone is to the point of arguing about it, then they're invested enough that they'll be highly susceptible to the backfire effect. (Instead it's better to make your arguments for the sake of unconvinced bystanders)
It takes effort and mindfulness to push back against the backfire effect, and a conscious effort to allow yourself to be wrong.
Jared Forsyth
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Marge Wu 吴静玫 likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Jared Forsyth • •@Jared Forsyth wouldn't surprise me, a lot of terms get formed in a positive place and corrupted over time.
The broader term is Abrahamic Faith. It has more valid use cases, but does suffer from the same problem of people using it to talk just about Christianity.
As beloved author Charles Stross (The Laundry Files) commented above, it's the Embrace Extend Eradicate practice, applied to religion.
like this
just adrienne and Marge Wu 吴静玫 like this.
Naomi
in reply to Zach Fine • • •@zachnfine @a13cui Which sums up pretty succinctly why Christianity is the way it is: It could really have done with some of that, instead of being so open and welcoming to all, that it is now very obviously the product of 2000 years of infiltration, appropriation, and bastardization, by every example of exactly the worst kind of self-serving people with power and privilege, Jesus warned about.
Thanks to that difference, try as they might to appropriate and bastardize Judaism - like they have so many other cultures - Christians have time and again, failed.
Where Christians go out of their way to eradicate basic critical thinking in those they indoctrinate, Judaism encourages it, and that provides a basic defense against the kind of corruption, that Christianity has utterly succumbed to.
'Those who have eyes shall see', and Jews see Christianity's leaders very clearly, for the wolves in sheep's clothing they always have been.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Naomi • •@Naomi @Zach Fine @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: So there's definitely some distinct history to what happened with Christianity.
It starts with the Apostles and namely with Luke arguing that Christians did not have to first be Jews. It's obvious why that argument won out (lower standards and dropping circumcision).
And then it was kicked into high-gear with Emperor Constantine who converted the whole Roman Empire to Christianity.
As an important bit of context, the Roman empire/faith was essentially the borg of religions. As it conquered cultures it declared that their faiths were all subsets of their own, assimilating them into their faith.
The issue between the Jews of Israel and Rome was rooted in the fact that Rome wanted to call our God just another manifestation of Zeus and we wholeheartedly rejected that (the story of Hannukah starts with the Romans trying to put up a statue of Zeus in front of the Temple).
So, when the emperor declared that Rome was now Christian, they immediately assimilated their own faith into Christianity. This is why the popular Christian afterlife mirrors the afterlife of the roman faith (seriously compare Heaven/Hell depictions with the Elysian Fields and Pits of Tartarus; and then contrast to the fact that Judaism has no established afterlife).
Dweebish likes this.
Hilary
in reply to Glyph • • •@glyph @foo @a13cui
This is worth reading in full, but one point to take away is that in Judaism abortion is not merely permitted (in certain circumstances). It is obligatory/required (in certain, more limited, circumstances). If continuing a pregnancy threatens a woman's life, abortion is obligatory.
This is complicated by another halachic principle, which is the obligation to abide by the (secular) laws of the place where one lives.
There can be direct conflict here.
Shiri Bailem likes this.
Zorin =^o.o^=
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •@a13cui This is great. I went to a catholic high school, and I remember contesting anything religious was a huge no-no. The word was the word, and arguing about it wasn't allowed.
Allowing even long-standing ideas to be challenged is one of the most important requirements for a society to progress.
Shiri Bailem likes this.
crows call me breadlady
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
korin
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Pedestriansfirst • •@Pedestriansfirst @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: they are in fact Jews and you won't find me pulling a "No True Scotsman" on that.
I will however always note that they're Zionists and that non-Zionists don't approve of Zionists.
For a Christian example, it's the difference between saying WBC isn't Christian vs saying WBC is condemned by most other Christians.
Making the Palestine argument applies specifically to the Zionist take that Israel (the political entity) and Judaism are inseparable, and it implies from that that all Jews support the actions of Israel as opposed to the majority (at least as I've seen) condemning it.
like this
just adrienne, Leszek Karlik and Dweebish like this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Zorin =^o.o^= • •@Zorin =^o.o^= @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: Agreed, I'm a fan of Mark Twain's (yes, the Mark Twain) commentary on the topic:
We persist and have great impact because knowledge and understanding are cherished, and all things old and new are challenged constantly. We don't claim perfection, being Jewish is all about the act of continually striving to do and be better.
like this
Zorin =^o.o^=, Christie and just adrienne like this.
reshared this
Zorin =^o.o^= and Johannes Silverfox 🦊 reshared this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •like this
ראַף 🟣 and just adrienne like this.
Naomi
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •@zachnfine @a13cui And this is why I'd much rather listen to Jews than Christians. You keep the parts of history that Christians have gone out of their way to bury, so your explanations actually make sense of the glaring disparities between what Jesus (a Jew) said, and what Christians, from the apostles onwards (Paul in particular), /say/ he said.
I mean, I can't even google anything related to the Bible, without getting endless pages of 'Good Christian Bible study' takes, twisting every word he said into its opposite.
Questioning that is why I got kicked out of Sunday school when I was still an infant, and it wasn't much longer before I realized Christianity was a very Roman creation, even with the poor, Christian education I was given.
Shiri Bailem likes this.
Eugene
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Eugene
in reply to Eugene • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Eugene • •Eugene likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Eugene • •like this
Eugene and Dweebish like this.
Pedestriansfirst
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to Pedestriansfirst • •@Pedestriansfirst @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: 80? that honestly is a lot lower than what I would have expected at this point
I won't say "bad Jews" because that's far too close to "No True Scotsman", they are Zionists and Zionism is Jewish Colonialism, which is a very bad take imo.
And no, you're not blocked. It wasn't a great take to start with, but it was understandable given the propensity for Christians to take the "No True Scotsman" fallacy against arguments such as that.
I believe in giving someone a chance first when there's any grey area on potential hate, plus it was a good excuse to outline the differences on a very common and hot topic that gentiles often know little about. And I think you learned something about Jewish society from it.
For more background, part of the problem with Zionists is that they're supported by White Supremacists and Nazis.
It sounds weird on the surface that Nazis would support Zionists, but it comes from a common White Supremacist principle of "Blood and Soil" in which they believe that different "races" have dominion over different lands (ie. white people over europe, Jews over Israel, Asians over Asia, etc). It's why you'll occasionally see someone spouting antisemitic bullshit, but then pivot to supporting Israel.
(Also "fun" trivia: this is why so many white people claim some vague distant "Cherokee Princess" in their background, it came from an effort to expand their blood and soil claim to the Americas)
like this
Patrick Poitras :opensuse:, just adrienne, Leszek Karlik and Dweebish like this.
Pedestriansfirst
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@Nicolai von Neudeck 🤒🤕 I saw in your about you're from Germany and yeah, it's bad everywhere (the honeymoon post-holocaust period is ending and anti-semitism is returning to the "norm"), just from what I understand there's still drastically more taught about the Holocaust and Naziism in Germany than in the US.
Here, we get little more than "Nazis hate Jews", "Nazis bad", and "Bad things happened at Auschwitz". If anything else is covered, it's merely glossed over.
Of course, we're also the country that throws hissy fits at the idea of taking down monuments to people who actively fought to keep slavery (not that it's over with in the US, we just made it state slavery)
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Pedestriansfirst • •@Pedestriansfirst @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: praying for peace is a constant for us, but we also believe in Tikkun Olam, it's our responsibility to continually work toward it as well.
I figured you were not Christian, when mentioning Palestine you were calm about it and responded reasonably... Christians tend to only really go that route if they're going to be frothing antisemites, so it'd be really surprising to me if you were. (Not impossible, just unlikely)
Part of the trouble is that in the west Christianity overshadows all other religions to the point that many atheists only known and understand Christianity when they're rejecting religion as a whole. And that's something I'm deeply conscious of.
... I also love getting into arguments with anti-theists because they get so incredibly confused at (a) rational arguments and (b) the fact that I'll context switch right along them when they're not even paying attention to their context. (I jokingly call these people theo-phobes after the idea of homophobes being self-hating homosexuals and I believe many of them have an indoctrinated belief in god and are repulsed by the thought that the things they were taught would be true)
like this
Patrick Poitras :opensuse: and just adrienne like this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •ראַף 🟣 likes this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •Pedestriansfirst
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Dean L. Surkin
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shaterri (he/him)
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem likes this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@Nicolai von Neudeck 🤒🤕 oof, for some reason I thought Germany was notable in taking them all down... but I really shouldn't be surprised.
I think it's both (a) and (b), after the war anti-semitism became shameful so it moved out of the public view... but also being out of the public limited it's spread.
But every year the holocaust gets more distant and the reaction to it becomes more and more muted as people try to claim that it's done and gone and not worth talking about anymore and with that Naziism becomes more and more a cartoon instead of a real threat... so of course it starts spreading again.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Pedestriansfirst • •like this
just adrienne and Dweebish like this.
Wayne is distracted reshared this.
Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@Emily K 🪬 @Jared Forsyth Agreed, I cite it as better only because it's actually used in broader valid cases (as an accurate classification of the faiths), but whenever they talk about individual beliefs... it turns to total crap real fast.
Majority of the time they're talking about Christianity, every once in a while they hit a valid chord between the big three... but it's a miracle if it's actually accurate to all Abrahamic Faiths.
just adrienne likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Shaterri (he/him) • •@Shaterri (he/him) Honestly I think this has been mostly good faith arguments given how people have responded to my replies. There's one where I drew the line feeling it was making it's way to bad faith pedantry... and the one worse than that you'll note their posts have disappeared or will soon because their server banned them (credit to Venera.social for responding quickly and decisively)
But I can see what people think of as bad faith. There's a lot of common anti-theist counter arguments that I'm familiar with, but I don't think any of them have gone beyond one post and in most cases took my reply graciously and learned something.
For instance calling out Palestine that one time, which while tiresome is understandable since Christians typically pull a "No True Scotsman" fallacy in response to things like that, which clearly marks them as not worth talking to. As tiresome as it is, it's a good barometer question for Jews imo.
just adrienne likes this.
assertchris
in reply to Zach Fine • • •assertchris
in reply to CaptMorgan • • •Content warning: religion
Shiri Bailem
in reply to assertchris • •@assertchris @Zach Fine @A13cui :perl: :opensuse: it's established well after that, that's prior to the Torah even being written and I believe it was established somewhere in the commentaries (like a millennia later) I think, but as I said no idea where.
It's not as hard to maintain your culture prior to being conquered by Rome and prior to Diaspora, but after it becomes vitally important to preserve your practices if you don't want them to dissolve into assimilation.
assertchris likes this.
Shiri Bailem
in reply to assertchris • •Content warning: religion
like this
assertchris and CaptMorgan like this.
Schafstelze
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Not only did he use the term to promote anti-islamism by claiming they are NOT part of our tradition and shouldn't be, but he also seems to have 'forgotten' the nasty details of that 'judao-christian tradition'...
He definitely belongs in that 99%-bracket.
Shiri Bailem likes this.
Philip N Cohen
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
Unknown parent • •@More Cowbell @raf I had to sit on this one for a while, but... you know that arguing with Jews over what is antisemitic is itself antisemitic?
And do you really think bigots are saying "Oh yeah, I'm absolutely a proud bigot!"? And that if they actually believe their bigotry that somehow frees them of being a bigot?
Shiri Bailem
in reply to Shiri Bailem • •Thank you so much to everyone who's shared this and asked questions!
From the comment section it seems to me a lot of people have learned some things about Judaism and how it differs from Christianity. We even exposed one raging antisemite troll who's been banned from their server (shoutout venera.social for having over a thousand users and taking care of it in around an hour).
There certainly was a lot of mild antisemitism throughout the comments, but as far as I can tell in most cases it was ignorance that has been relieved by this!
(Remember kids, pulling a "what about israel?" is rude to do out of nowhere, but if someone supports the occupation they're bad for being a Zionist and that still doesn't permit you to denigrate their faith because it's the same faith as those who reject the occupation)
like this
Moved to CatCatNya, undead enby of the apocalypse, NullNoMore, spooky Ske-lil-ton 🦇, novatorine 🏴🏳️⚧️, gim, eingy and Pteryx the Puzzle Secretary like this.
reshared this
SCSalon, Left Field Farm and Jeff Cuscutis reshared this.
heather gold
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •heather gold
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem
in reply to heather gold • •heather gold
in reply to Shiri Bailem • • •Shiri Bailem